| 2021 | Alexa Raphael | Villanova University |
| 2020 | Kylee Amato | Bentley University |
| Faith Camilleri | Adelphi University |
| Kayla Haywood | Iona College |
| Kaitlin Houser | East Stroudsburg University |
| Angela Lignelli | Adelphi University |
| Nicolette Luzzi | Indian River State College |
| Gianna Palmisano | Quinnipiac University |
| Annabella Pisapia | LaSalle College |
| Kasey Sekula | Fairfield University |
| Rylie Spiegel | Massachusetts Institute of Technology |
| Kristyn Smith | Manhattan College |
| Emily Talkow | Washington University, Saint Louis |
| Julia Vincent | Mount Saint Mary's University |
| 2019 | Lauren Card | University of Hartford |
| Danielle Dabroski | Villanova University |
| Caylee English | University of Hartford |
| Elizabeth Grant | Philadelphia Sciences |
| Johanna Rivera | Felician |
| Gianna Sarlo | Boston College |
| Alyssa Segnello | University of Scranton |
| Sarah Stocker | Boston College |
| 2018 | Nicole Gravagna | Seton Hall University |
| Lilly James | Stockton College |
| Katie Kudlacik | James Madison University |
| Ashley Lupi | Georgian Court University |
| Michelle McMillan | St. Joseph University |
| Amy Petrovich | Sacred Heart University |
| Logan Robinson | Carleton College |
| Alessandra Rodriguez | Rowan University |
| Sarah Taffet | Fordham University |
| Kelly Toomey | UNC Wilmington |
| 2017 | Ashley Antonazzo | Central CT State University |
| Brittany Giordano | Post University |
| Marisa Jenkins | Providence College |
| Melissa Landry | Bentley College |
| Giovanna Russomanno | Felician College |
| Allie Schey | Shenandoah University |
| Olivia Sprofera | Providence College |
| Jade Warner | Central CT State University |
| Brooke Wiarda | Susquehanna University |
| 2016 | Zoe Bender | Wagner College |
| Alicia Bertolino | Central CT State University |
| Madison Bialkowski | Gettysburg University |
| Ashley Conroy | Williams College |
| Elizabeth Cowell | Gettysburg University |
| Annie Flego | Providence College |
| Rachel Grabowski | East Stroudsburg University |
| Alexa Guglielmino | Slippery Rock University |
| Brooke Lichty | California PA University |
| Akilah Mouzan | University of Illinois |
| Alexie Piccinich | Franklin and Marshall |
| Sara Seuffert | Gettysburg University |
| Halley Smith | Post University |
| Larissa Spellman | University of Kentucky |
| 2015 | Sophie Blasius | Syracuse University |
| Ally Dabroski | University of Rhode Island |
| Evie Diaz | Long Island University |
| Leah Georgatos | Alfred University |
| Cassandra Gerard | Rowan University |
| Tricia Griffin | Long Island University |
| Gabrielle Lombardi | New York University |
| Cynthia Meringer | Fairfield University |
| Alexa Smedberg | Franklin and Marshall |
| Jenn Tellefsen | Florida State Jacksonville |
| Kali Wolfer | Franklin and Marshall |
| 2014 | Mia Baldassari | Siena College |
| Marisa Barnes | Stevens institute Technology |
| Hanna Bibeault | Stockton College |
| Jessica Dresswick | Boston College |
| Jada Fields | Hampton University |
| Collen Frank | Umass - Lowell |
| Madison Housel | University of Rhode Island |
| Daniella Ibarra | Iowa University |
| Stephanie Thomas | Lafayette College |
| 2013 | Nikki Carillo | St. Josephs University, PA |
| Alyssa Dewes | Syracuse University |
| Katie Johnson | Central CT State University |
| Cassidy Trause | Temple University |
| Laren Visconti | Manhattan College |
| Jordyn White | Syracuse University |
| 2012 | Kiki Baldassari | Providence College |
| Gianna Cuffari | Stockton College |
| Lexi Knief | Penn State University |
| Melissa Phelan | Stony Brook University |
| Lisa Stacevicz | University of Delaware |
| Ally Thomas | Lafayette College |
| Carley Picccinich | University of Notre Dame |
| 2011 | Taylor Boffalo | Ramapo College |
| Isabella Corrao | Virginia Tech |
| Fran D'Amato | St. Peter's College |
| Maggy Fermo | Drexel University |
| Tori Feorenzo | St. Peter's College |
| Cora Ianiro | Fordham University |
| Jessica Mahoney | Temple University |
| Caitlin O'Connor | Bloomsburg University |
| Jen Retzer | University of Pennsylvania |
| Erin Trippi | Hofstra University |
| Victoria Vergona | Lafayette College |
| Lacey Waldrop | Florida State University |
| 2010 | Caitlyn Dean | William Paterson University |
| Claire Fitzgerald | Haverford College |
| Devin Griglik | Philadelphia University |
| Nicole Hagerty | Hofstra University |
| Christina Miguel | Babson College |
| Nikki Osofsky | Farfield University |
| Steph Pasquale | Temple University |
| Sarah Prezioso | Temple University |
| Gabby Spinelly | Rutgers - Newark |
| Jess Stofik | Providence College |
| 2009 | Jen Keller | Manhattan College |
| Megan McDevitt | Manhattan College |
| Meredith Moore | Radford University |
| Brittney Palish | Colorado State University |
| Julie Shaw | University of the Sciences |
| 2008 | Meg Garlasco | Scranton University |
| Ashley Martinez | Dominican College |
| Jamie Price | Bucknell University |
| Alyssa Sceppaguercio | Siena College |
| Brittney Sheppard | Farleigh Dickenson University |
| Allison Smith | Manhattan College |
| Amanda Stacevicz | University of Delaware |
| 2007 | Monica Evangalista | Manhattan College |
| Paige Kemezis | Ohio University |
| Becky LaMarca | Villanova University |
| Jess O'Boyle | Villanova University |
| Alisha Prystowsky | University of Pennsylvania |
| Jaci Rahey | Manhattan College |
| Courtney Taylor | Delaware State University |
| 2006 | Megan Livesey | University of Pittsburgh |
| Amy Piccinich | Lehigh University |
| Jackie Turco | St. Francis University, PA |
| 2005 | Jackie Araneo | Princeton University |
| Gina Capardi | Fordham University |
| Danielle Just | Manhattan College |
| Meg Picinic | Robert Morris University |
| Jamie Piela | Siena College |
| Kristen Schindler | Brown University |
| Odallis Torres | University of Rhode Island |
| 2004 | Lauren Bierman | Princeton University |
| Allison Ling | Cornell University |
| Christinia Lizzi | The College of New Jersey |
| Anj Piela | Siena College |
| Meg Schaffer | St. Peter's College |
| Jen Sutliff | Lafayette College |
| Jess Valentini | Bryant University |
| 2003 | Amanda Byrnes | Bloomfield College |
| Courtney Gambetta | Wagner College |
| Krystle Henry | Fordham University |
| Gianna Lopreato | Lafayette College |
| 2002 | Dana Berenghelli | Fordham University |
| Jill Clementi | St. Josephs University, PA |
| Christine Doyle | Coastal Carolina University |
| Christa Fasano | Siena College |
| Rachel Fleitell | Brown University |
| Christina Gillman | Rutgets University |
| Jill Medea | Manhattan College |
| Thanni Totaro | University of Vermont |
| 2001 | Erica Ennis | University of North Carolina |
| Danielle Green | Felician College |
| Leslie Konsig | Sacred Heart University |
| Erin Kummerfelt | Mount St. Mary College |
| Dana Pasini | Monmouth University |
| 2000 | Maleka Brown | Monmouth University |
| Brielle Cosentino | Rutgers University |
| Diana Fasano | Fairfield University |
| Alyssa Hayden | College of the Holy Cross |
| Tammy Lascar | Monmouth University |
| Tori Magatti | St. Bonaventure University |
| Alex Picillo | Hartford University |
| 1999 | Meaghan Asselta | Rutgers University |
| Kim Divencenzo | Seton Hall University |
| 1998 | Lee-ann Gade | University of Delaware |
| Patty Kern | Stockton College |
| Desiree McGhie | St. Josephs University, PA |
| Allison Tan | Haverford College |
| Angie Totaro | University of Vermont |
| Jackie Trapp | Bucknell University |
| 1997 | Kristen Gengaro | Yale University |
| Kim Mahoney | Caldwell College |
| Kristen Puzio | FDU-Madison |
| 1996 | Danielle Brodo | Caldwell College |
| Gianna Caruso | Long Island University |
| Jelle Della Vope | Western CT State University |
| Amy Hessels | Lafayette College |
| Sarah Negra | Central CT State University |
| Fifi Silva | Drew University |
